On August 3, 1492 Christopher Columbus and 87 other men looked out at the endless horizon of the Atlantic Ocean where their journey into the unknown would begin. Since that day the earth has been mapped, technology has advanced and modern travel has made this journey considerably more comfortable. To make the same trip today you just have to buy a ticket, drive yourself to the airport and you’ll be across the ocean before lunch. The contribution to society that this ease of travel has made is incalculable, but nonetheless something was lost in the process.
It’s hard to imagine the type of person that would have been standing next to Columbus that day, willing to get on a wooden ship and sail for months, further and further into the belly of the great deep without knowing if they would ever see land again. It’s hard to imagine because that person is all but extinct. The great unknown is known. Every discovery dilutes the adventure, reduces the nerve required to make the leap. Every step forward erodes ever so slightly the adventurers spirit. The same trip these men risked everything to make can be made today with an enthusiasm that feels more akin to indifference. A necessary progress but we’ve lost a part of the human spirit in the process.
I believe we are now in the process of losing another figure that loomed large in my early life: the Meathead. The Meathead was stereotyped as being just your average dumb jock, but if you count yourself amongst the ranks of meatheads (which I do) you know that the spirit of the Meathead is much more than that.
Sure we wanted to be bigger, faster and stronger, that much is true. We also had no idea what to do to make it happen. What separates the Meathead from the rest is that the Meathead never lets his ignorance stop him from the attempt. We didn’t need to know much, we went with our guts. If we wanted bigger arms, we gathered up the boys and did as many bicep curls as we could handle. If it hurt, it must be working. If it was harder, then it must be better. That was our approach.
The internet, in particular the modern internet, has allowed people access to a near infinite amount of quality information at their fingertips. The average person walking into the gym for the first time probably knows more about what they should do than I did after a few years of training. Far from dumb these young kids just starting to lift are bordering on the nerdy. You might hear a 16 year old say something like, “That felt easy, but I’m only supposed to do 20% of my volume above RPE 8 for this training block.” As a meathead it hurts my heart. Is that mentality smart? Yes. Is it going to produce better results than I ever got at that age? Yes. But the thought of being in the gym, the music is going, the air is almost buzzing with energy, you’re having an absolute day, and you’re not going to send it because it might mess up your training protocol? It’s a travesty, an assault on the very essence of man.
The progress and the results people are able to achieve now in such a short period of time is a true testament to the power of knowing and implementing correct training. Many lifters have their training mapped out for months. Optimized for success. It’s a powerful tool, and it works. But again, as the unknown becomes a little more known we lose a little bit of something in the process.
One of the great Meathead works of our time foretold us of this day, that the inevitable would come. Rocky 4, man vs. man, country vs. country, no money, no title, just glory on the line that Christmas Day. What we also see is Drago, with the entire weight of the Russian government behind him, utilizing every evidenced based high tech training protocol they could come up with. He’s surrounded by doctors, machines, trainers, drugs, all to optimize him into an unbeatable machine. The only problem is that he was going up against the Meathead messiah, Rocky Balboa. Rocky decided the best way to combat Drago’s superior training strategy was to climb mountains by himself, run through rivers in the Russian wilderness, lift stones with a pulley, all while looking absolutely gassed. We root for this. Why? They could have easily given Rocky better and smarter training to try and defeat the Russian. But that doesn’t call to us. Why do we want the primitive method to win? All true Meatheads recognize that there is something in a man that wants to believe that it doesn’t just come down to how good your training is, that there is that something inside that can rise up.
Unfortunately for the Meathead species, the training techniques, protocols supplement advancements, etc. do really seem to make the biggest difference. It seems like our story will end a little less like Rocky 4 and a little more like the tale of John Henry. The man who died of exhaustion trying to out dig a machine on the old railroad.
This is good right? People will push boundaries farther, get bigger, stronger, faster. Records will fall and we’ll move on to bigger and better things. More people will achieve and succeed on a higher level.
Maybe.
When someone is about to propose, most of the time they are understandably nervous. They have seen relationships crumble around them before. They know people who have gotten divorces that have all but ruined their lives and torn families apart. What if it’s the wrong person? What if it doesn’t work out. It would be nice to be able to see the answer before you pop the question. To know if you were about to make a giant mistake.
That thought process is perfectly logical, and it’s understandable to want to have that information, even if it’s impossible to actually get. But in my opinion it’s better that we don’t get what we want in this circumstance. Marriage is a vow, a commitment, a promise you make to one person that you are going to be there with them no matter what happens. You have no idea what is coming next and you make that promise anyway. It’s a giant leap of faith to make that type of commitment with that much unknown. If you were to know the outcome before you proposed it wouldn’t really be much of a commitment then would it? If there is no risk then what exactly are you committed to?
In this instance you get what you want to ensure that your marriage is going to make it, but in the process you actually change the whole thing. The act is sterilized with certainty.
The fact that we know so much about training now, and how to get the results we are after kills some of the mystery, it shows us the clear path to results. We wanted results for sure, and if someone had the answers we would have taken them in a heartbeat. But the Meathead life wasn’t about the results, even though we might have thought it was. It was about meeting the boys at the gym and seeing who would say they had enough first. The regular characters in the gym and all their peculiarities. The days where you feel good and go off schedule and the whole crew rises to the occasion. A day when nothing is planned but a PR just comes down unscheduled from the heavens. The thought of it is enough to make your hair stand on end.
The sterilized monotony of the perfect training protocol where every rep, weight, macro, calorie, is all laid out on an excel spreadsheet, still takes commitment, still takes dedication and maybe even more discipline. But for me it doesn’t stir that something inside that I don’t quite have a name for.
You see, being a Meathead isn’t just about the gym, it’s a mentality. If I’m golfing I am almost certain that I’ll score better if I just put the driver away and take a more conservative approach, but I’ll quit golfing all together before I stop hitting the driver. I might put 4 or 5 balls into the trees but what’s the point of even going out if you don’t even give yourself a chance to do something big?
In the age of analytics, where football coaches are making their calls off of percentage sheets, and every baseball team is trading players based on a probability algorithm, the Meathead is going to fall by the wayside. The part that hurts the most is that those methods will prove to be more effective than our primitive ways. All is not lost, there are some trying to breath life into our kind. David Goggins is grinding his knees down to nothing as we speak, with the noble hope that more of us will rise from the pulverized ashes of his tibia, like a Phoenix.
I respect the few leading the charge, fighting against our inevitable extinction. It is our way. I hope to impart our culture onto my children, however futile the attempt may be. We all hope to be Rocky Balboa, but in the end we’re more likely to end up like John Henry.
A man is nothing but a man,
But before I let your steam drill beat me down,
I'd die with a hammer in my hand, Lord, Lord,
I'd die with a hammer in my hand.
John Henry by Anonymous